San Andres: a Caribbean island that crams more than its fair share of clichés into 26 square kilometers. Most visitors stick to the all-inclusive resorts along the crowded northern beaches, but those in the know head south or east for more genuine stays. Think local vibes, authentic eats, and less beach chair competition.

## Where to stay

**Coco Plum Bay, not Spratt Bight.** Spratt Bight is the default for first-timers, with its white sands and cocktail bars overrun with sunburnt tourists. Instead, head to Coco Plum Bay. It's quieter, the water's just as clear, and you can enjoy fresh-off-the-boat seafood at Donde Francesca while your toes sink into the sand.

**San Luis for local flavor.** San Luis feels like a different world compared to the commercial heart of the island. Here, colorful wooden houses lean into the tropics, and the rhythm is decidedly Caribbean. Stay close to the area around La Loma for a true taste of island life, where each corner seems to lead to a reggae beat or a food stall selling rondon.

**La Loma for views and culture.** A stay in La Loma offers sweeping sea views and a deep dive into the island’s cultural tapestry. It’s perched high enough to give you a break from the beach hustle, and close enough to venture down when the mood strikes. Don’t skip a visit to the Baptist Church for vistas over the entire island.

## When to go

Visit in February or March, when the island is sunny and breezy, perfect for dodging the rainy seasons. Avoid the winter months — December and January are congested, with tourists piling in.

Ask your host about the best local eats and the most secluded spots. Whether it's grabbing a mix of Colombian and Caribbean grub at La Regatta or finding a hammock at El Acuario, San Andres will reward those willing to look beyond the obvious. Happy stays!